Sunday, March 7, 2021

Third Sunday of Lent: First Scrutiny

Readings: Exo 17:3-7; Ps 95:1-2.6-9; Rom 5:1-2.5-8; John 4:5-42

Because at this Mass we are celebrating the first of three scrutinies for our Elect, we are using the readings from Year A of the Lectionary. These readings are geared towards Christian initiation. Since we are all preparing to renew our baptismal promises at Easter, these readings speak to us all.

Our reading from Exodus tells about when Moses, under great duress, struck the rock, making water flow from it to give drink to the parched Israelites and their livestock. Taking the near mutiny to the LORD in prayer, Moses said, “What shall I do with this people? A little more and they will stone me!”1 Thirst in the desert, it seems, was getting the better of everyone. After striking the rock with his stick and making water flow from it, Moses named this place “Massah and Meribah, because the Israelites quarreled there and tested the LORD, saying, ‘Is the LORD in our midst or not?’”2

Our responsorial Psalm, Psalm 95, is the Psalm with which the Church traditionally begins the Liturgy of the Hours each day: “Today listen to the voice of LORD, do not grow stubborn as your fathers did in the wilderness, when at Meribah and Massah they challenged me and provoked me although they had seen all of my works.”3 Massah is from the Hebrew verb “to test,” while Meribah, is derived from the Hebrew word for quarreling.”4 So, by opening each day with Psalm 95, the Church, the people of God, are invited to remember what the Lord has done for us, which remembrance should ease our anxiety about the present and the future.

In her encounter with the Archangel Gabriel, Mary, during the Annunciation, which solemnity we celebrate on 25 March, in convincing the Blessed Virgin to cooperate with God, called to mind what God had already done. He reminded her that Elizabeth, the mother of John the Baptist, had conceived a child despite, like Sarah and Hannah, being beyond child-bearing years, saying, in effect: “You doubt what God can do? Look at what God has already done.”5 Looking backward helps Mary look ahead. As Kierkegaard sagely observed: “Life can only be understood backwards, but it must be lived forward.”6

In our first reading, while the people invoke being led out of Egypt, they attribute this to Moses, not to God (“Why then did you bring us up out of Egypt? To have us die of thirst with our children and our livestock?”7). Further, Moses does not remind them that it was God, not him, who delivered them, nor does he bring to mind the many signs and wonders that were part of their deliverance. The lesson here is obvious: if you look back over your own life, God, by various ways and means has led you to this moment and is leading you on to the saving waters of baptism.

Our reading from St Paul's Letter to the Romans is an exhortation to hope. Of the three theological virtues (faith, hope, and love), hope is the least understood. While one who hopes aspires to something not yet realized, hope is distinct from mere wishing. Hope is the flower of faith and love is their fruit. Hope, far from being a mere wish, is attained through experience- the experience of finding yourself on the far side of optimism.

The hope we have, which can be described as thirst, Paul tells us, “does not disappoint, because the love of God has been poured out into our hearts through the holy Spirit that has been given to us.”8 We must be careful not to sentimentalize this. Having the love of God poured into your heart is what brings about conversion. Conversion into the image of Christ is an often agonizing, lifelong process.



In our Gospel this morning, which tells of Jesus’s encounter with the Samaritan woman at the well of Jacob, what the woman said to the Lord indicates that Jews and Samaritans, while closely related, did not like each other very much. Usually, Jews going from Galilee, Jesus’s native region, to Jerusalem, rather than walk the direct route through Samaria, by-passed this region by going east and walking along the west bank of the Jordan River to Jericho and from there heading up the mountain to the Holy City.

The mere fact that Jesus, along with his (clearly very uneasy) disciples, is passing through Samaria, is no small thing in and of itself. The unusual nature of this episode is further brought home when Jesus begins to speak, not only to a Samaritan but to an unaccompanied woman: two things an observant male Jew would assiduously avoid!

This woman went out to fetch water, not at the usual time, toward evening, but at midday, perhaps because she knew she would be alone. Likely due to her having been married five times and currently living with a man who was not her husband, she was viewed as a bit of a hussy, someone to be shunned by decent people. Not only did the Lord not shun her, he engaged her.

Jesus did so by appealing to what it was she was really thirsty for- unconditional acceptance, life-giving love, the more for which we long even in life’s most contented moments. Jesus offered her the water that would slake her deep, existential thirst, the water that becomes in the one who imbibes “a spring of water welling up to eternal life.”9 Wisely, she eagerly accepted it.

Jesus then bids her go fetch her husband, which occasions her oblique confession, “I do not have a husband.”10 Upon this admission, we see Divine Mercy at work when Jesus says to her, in what I can only imagine with the greatest of tenderness: “You are right in saying, ‘I do not have a husband.’ For you have had five husbands, and the one you have now is not your husband. What you have said is true.”11

I don’t know about you, but I find this to be very good news: the Lord knows everything about you and still loves you completely. While Jesus takes you as you are, he is not content to leave you where he found you. If you were fine, why would you feel so unfulfilled? Why would you bother being here today? Jesus is leading you to the fulfillment of what you truly desire, what St. Augustine, in a letter to the Roman widow Proba, called “the life that is truly life.”12

As a result of her encounter, the Samaritan woman was clearly changed. Jesus revealed to her that he is the Messiah, the one awaited by both Jews and Samaritans, the one in and through whom God would no longer be worshiped either on Mount Gerazim or in Jerusalem, but be worshiped by true worshipers, who are temples of God's Spirit, anywhere and everywhere, like in Bountiful, Utah.

Like those who also encountered the Lord up close and in person, this woman could not keep this good news to herself, she was compelled to tell others what Jesus had done for her. Telling others what Jesus has done for you is called “evangelization.”

My brothers and sisters, our dear Elect, today, Jesus invites you, indeed all of us, to the water. Specifically, to the water of baptism. He invites us not only to drink but to be immersed in the very life of God, who is Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The essence of divine life is love, in Greek agape, which refers to self-giving, self-sacrificing love, most powerfully expressed with Jesus on the cross. Being thus refreshed, you are to worship God in spirit and in truth, witnessing to what God has done for you in Christ by the power of their Holy Spirit.


1 Exodus 17:4.
2 Exodus 17:7.
3 Psalm 95:7-9.
4 Richard J. Clifford, SJ, “Exodus,” in The New Jerome Biblical Commentary, 51.
5 Luke 1:26-38.
6 J. Collins, The Mind of Kierkegaard. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1953, 37.
7 Exodus 17:3.
8 Romans 5:5.
9 John 4:14.
10 John 4:17.
11 John 4:17-18.
12 St. Augustine, “Letter to Proba.”

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Mystery of the Incarnation

Sunset marks the beginning of the Fourth Sunday of Advent. Tonight, we light all the candles! At the Easter Vigil, as the deacon enters the...