This part of his letter particularly struck me:
Many Californians feel that those who commit brutal crimes deserve to die. But as Governor, I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them. I do, however, pray that this action will finally separate the memories of the victims of these crimes from the fate of those who harmed themNonetheless, I don't agree with what he goes on to write about crime and punishment, which I understand politically and reject morally.
Forty years ago, in November 1986, citing his Catholic faith, New Mexico Governor, Tony Anaya, as he was leaving the governorship, commuted the death sentence for all 5 prisoner's on death row in New Mexico. I remember this well as I lived in New Mexico at the time. Remember, too, that it was only 1976 when the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty.
As a Catholic, I affirm what the Catechism teaches with regard to the death penalty. This section has been revised twice since the Catechism's promulgation: once by John Paul II and then by Pope Francis. Both papal edits are on the same trajectory.
Recourse to the death penalty on the part of legitimate authority, following a fair trial, was long considered an appropriate response to the gravity of certain crimes and an acceptable, albeit extreme, means of safeguarding the common good.I wrote about Pope Francis' change back in 2018 when he made it (see "State your peace tonight").
Today, however, there is an increasing awareness that the dignity of the person is not lost even after the commission of very serious crimes. In addition, a new understanding has emerged of the significance of penal sanctions imposed by the state. Lastly, more effective systems of detention have been developed, which ensure the due protection of citizens but, at the same time, do not definitively deprive the guilty of the possibility of redemption.
Consequently, the Church teaches, in the light of the Gospel, that “the death penalty is inadmissible because it is an attack on the inviolability and dignity of the person”, and she works with determination for its abolition worldwide (CCC, sec. 2267)
Last month, in the wake of a highly publicized claim that the forthcoming execution of of Nidal Hassan would be livestreamed, Pope Leo strongly reiterated his and the Church's opposition, not just to the barbaric idea of a livestreamed execution, but to death penalty as such. Posting on X, the Pontiff insisted:
The death penalty is inadmissible because it is an attack on the inviolability and dignity of the person. The common good can be safeguarded and the requirements of justice can be met without recourse to capital punishment: effective systems of detention have been developed that protect citizens while at the same time do not completely deprive those who are guilty of the possibility of redemption
In September of last year, responding to questions about Senator Durbin declining a Church honor that was to be bestowed on him in the Holy Father's native Chicago, Pope Leo said quite bluntly:
Someone who says 'I'm against abortion but says I am in favor of the death penalty' is not really pro-life (see "The Unreceived Teaching"- it is largely, almost exclusively, in the U.S., where support for the death penalty remains quite high, that Catholics seem not to have received this teaching)The imago Dei is ineradicable, and that is foundational to any truly Christian anthropology.
While we're calling to mind that even a person who has committed a brutal crime still bears the divine image, it seems important to recount the horrific spectacle of the State of Tennessee's terribly botched attempt to execute Christa Pike. Pike's was not the first execution to go horrificially wrong. Since 2020, there have been no fewer than 10 botched executions. Eight of these were attempted lethal injections. One was by firing squad and the other was an attempt to kill by nitrogen hypoxia, which took more than 30 minutes. Five of the ten have occurred since 2024.
The eighth amendment to the U.S. constituion clearly states that "cruel and unusual punishments" are not to be inflicted. By his death and resurrection, as well as in his teaching, our Lord brought an end to the lex talionis.
Make no mistake, that the death penalty is inadmissible and should be abolished worldwide is the official teaching of the Church. The California Catholic Conference, which consists of all the Catholic bishops in California, issued a statement in the wake of Governor Newsom's executive action. In part, the statement reads:
For California’s Catholic community, opposition to the death penalty flows from the conviction that every person is created in the image and likeness of God. In justice, we uphold a consistent ethic of life, protecting the unborn, the vulnerable, victims of violence, and those who are incarcerated. A properly formed conscience motivates individuals and communities to defend all human life because it recognizes the inviolable human dignity in every person.I will continue to preach and teach what the Church teaches and continue to take all the slings and arrows of the dissenters. Is that to say it's not a matter we shouldn't discuss? Not all. Discussion is one thing, but Catholics who are certain they're right contra the Church's authentic magisterium is another thing entirely.
With this decision, men and women who have been living under a death sentence have the opportunity for repentance, transformation, and rehabilitation
You are free to agree or disagree, the Church has no mechanism to force you one way or the other. This is as it should be. But the Church has the duty to boldly and courageously proclaim the Gospel.
Believing themselves to literally by more Catholic than the Pope, there are some who quite shamelessly attack the Church's ministers for teaching what the Church teaches. Be that as it may, it's important to continue to teach in season and out, letting the chips fall where they will.
November is the month we pray for the dead. Let's pray for the repose of the souls of all those killed by acts of violence. We should also pray for those who survive them, the ones who bear the brunt of these violent crimes.
And like Saint Thérèse, who fervently prayed for the repentance of the murderer Henri Pranzini, let us also pray that in the time granted them, those among the 548 whose sentences Governor Newsom commuted who have not yet done so, will repent of their crimes. Pray also for those who minister in prisons.
Our traditio for this first Friday in November is by a group that is still playing: The Red Rockers. Their cover of the Johnny Cash classic "Folsom Prison Blues" came to mind.





